How to Get an Insurance Estimate for a Damage Claim

how to get an insurance estimate

After your home is damaged, you can get an insurance estimate from three sources: the adjuster your insurance company assigns, a contractor you ask to bid the repairs, or a public adjuster who prepares an estimate on your behalf. Your insurer’s adjuster writes an estimate as a normal part of handling the claim, and you’re free to gather independent estimates alongside it. At Alliance Adjustment Group, we help Pennsylvania homeowners understand each of these estimates and how they fit together.

Who Can Give You an Insurance Estimate?

Each source plays a different role, and many homeowners end up with more than one estimate on the same claim.

Your Insurance Company’s Adjuster

When you file a claim, your insurer assigns an adjuster, either a staff employee or an independent adjuster contracted by the company. The adjuster inspects the damage, reviews it against your policy, and writes the estimate the insurer uses to calculate payment. There is no charge to you for this estimate.

A Contractor

A roofer, restoration company, or general contractor can inspect the damage and give you a bid for what they would charge to do the work. Contractor bids are a useful real-world check on repair costs, though they aren’t always broken out line by line the way an insurance estimate is.

A Public Adjuster

A public adjuster is licensed to represent the policyholder in a claim. We document the loss, prepare a detailed estimate, and present it to the insurance company on your behalf. Public adjusters are typically paid a percentage of the claim payment, as set out in a written contract. The main difference between a public adjuster vs. insurance adjuster comes down to who each one represents.

How to Get an Insurance Estimate After Damage, Step-by-Step:

  1. Make the property safe and prevent further damage. Cover a damaged roof, shut off water, or board up a broken window. Most policies expect reasonable steps to limit further loss, so keep receipts for any emergency repairs.
  2. Report the claim to your insurer. Note the claim number and the name of the adjuster assigned to you. Pennsylvania regulations set timelines for investigating claims, which also shape how long an insurance company has to pay a claim in PA. 
  3. Document everything before cleanup. Take wide shots and close-ups of every affected area, record video, and write down when the damage happened. Keep damaged materials if you safely can. Knowing how to organize photos for an insurance claim makes every estimate easier to prepare and compare.
  4. Be present for the adjuster’s inspection. Walk the adjuster through every affected area, including attics, crawl spaces, and closets, and share your photos and notes.
  5. Get contractor bids. Ask two or three licensed, insured local contractors to inspect the same damage and bid the same scope of work so the numbers are comparable.
  6. Ask for itemized line items. A single lump-sum price is hard to compare against an insurance estimate. Ask each contractor to list quantities, materials, and labor separately. If you’re preparing your own, learning how to write an estimate for an insurance claim helps you match the format adjusters use.
  7. Compare the estimates line by line. Differences usually come down to scope (what’s included), quantities (how much), or pricing (unit costs). When your insurance estimate is lower than your contractor’s, that comparison shows you exactly where the gap is so you can discuss it with your adjuster.

What a Good Estimate Includes

Whether it comes from your insurer, a contractor, or our team, a complete repair estimate should cover:

  • Scope of work: A clear description of what is being repaired or replaced, room by room or area by area.
  • Line items: Each task listed separately with a quantity and unit, such as square feet of drywall or squares of roofing.
  • Labor and materials: Costs for each, either shown separately or built into the unit price for each line.
  • Overhead and profit: When a job needs a general contractor to coordinate several trades, estimates often add overhead and profit to cover that contractor’s business costs. A common industry convention is 10% for each, though whether it applies depends on your policy and the complexity of the repair.
  • Code upgrades: Local building codes may require work beyond restoring what was there, such as updated electrical or roof decking. Whether these costs are covered depends on your policy’s ordinance or law coverage and its limits.
  • Xactimate-style pricing: Many insurers, adjusters, and contractors use estimating software such as Xactimate, which assigns unit prices from regional price lists that are updated regularly. When estimates use the same format and pricing source, it’s much easier to compare them line by line.

How to Read the Estimate Your Insurer Sends You

Insurance estimates can be long, but they follow a predictable structure:

  1. Start with the summary page. Look for the replacement cost value (RCV), depreciation, actual cash value (ACV), your deductible, and the net payment.
  2. Check the line items. Each line should describe the work, the quantity, and the unit cost. Confirm every damaged area you documented appears somewhere.
  3. Understand depreciation. Depreciation reduces older items’ value based on age and condition. Many replacement cost policies let you recover some or all of it after repairs are completed, so note whether it’s listed as recoverable.
  4. Note any limits or exclusions. If an item is reduced or left out, the estimate or letter should reference the policy language behind that decision.
  5. Ask questions. If something is unclear or appears to be missing, contact your adjuster. Estimates are often revised when additional damage is found, and a request for that revision is commonly called a supplement.

Estimating Home Replacement Cost for Your Policy

Replacement cost for a policy is a different question from a claim estimate. It’s what it would cost to rebuild your home today, which is not the same as its market value. A rough starting point is your finished square footage multiplied by local construction costs per square foot, adjusted for features such as roofing type, finishes, and custom work.

Your insurance agent can run a replacement cost calculation, and a local builder can offer a second opinion. It’s worth reviewing the figure every year or two and after any renovation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are insurance estimates free?

The estimate your insurer’s adjuster writes comes at no cost to you. Most contractors provide repair bids for free, though some charge for detailed estimates on larger jobs. Public adjusters are typically paid a percentage of the claim payment rather than a separate estimate fee.

Why is my contractor’s estimate higher than my insurer’s?

The difference usually comes from scope, quantities, or pricing, such as a contractor including code-required work or overhead and profit that the first insurance estimate didn’t. Comparing both estimates line by line is the clearest way to see where they differ.

Can I get more than one estimate?

Yes. You can collect bids from several contractors and share them with your adjuster. Having more than one estimate gives everyone a clearer picture of local repair costs.

How long does it take to get an insurance estimate?

It depends on the size of the loss and how busy adjusters are, especially after a widespread storm. In Pennsylvania, insurers must complete their investigation within 30 days of being notified of a claim unless it can’t reasonably be done in that time. If it can’t, they must give you a written explanation for the delay, and again every 45 days, along with when to expect a decision (31 Pa. Code § 146.6). 

What if I think the insurance estimate is too low?

Knowing what to do if your insurance estimate is too low starts with a conversation: ask your adjuster to explain the items in question, and share your photos and contractor bids so both sides are working from the same information.

Questions About Your Insurance Estimate?

If you’ve received an insurance estimate and aren’t sure what it covers, or you’d like help putting together your own, our team is glad to talk it through. We’ll review the estimate with you, explain how it lines up with your policy, and help you understand your options. Contact us today: call Alliance Adjustment Group at (267) 880-3000, or stop by our office at 435 N Main St in Doylestown.


Disclaimer: The information provided on this website is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, insurance policies and regulations can vary. It is important to consult with your specific insurance provider or a qualified professional for advice tailored to your individual circumstances.